Rich Gersten – True Beauty Capital and Investment Opportunities
07/05/2020 by The Red Tree
Last year was a record-breaking one for beauty investment. According to Capstone Headwaters, there were 148 personal care deals, up from 118 in 2018. Big-name targets such as Tatcha, Drunk Elephant and Elemis fetched jaw-dropping sums of $500 million to $900 million, and plenty of smaller brands like Herbivore, ZitSticka and Beekeeper’s Naturals received cash infusions. Early signs pointed to 2020 continuing apace. In the second week of January, clean color cosmetics brands Kosas and Ilia both revealed new funding rounds. The industry had its eye on rising stars like Moon Juice, Milk Makeup, Pat McGrath Labs and Glossier as possible strategic pickups or IPOs at hefty valuations. In mid-March, though, beauty M&A ground to a halt when Americans woke up to the severity of coronavirus, which had already been roiling Asia and Europe. Within two weeks, most U.S. business was at a standstill, where it predominantly remains.
The conditions may not be ideal for launching a private equity firm specializing in emerging beauty and personal care businesses, but, if anyone can ferret out quality opportunities in an uncertain market, it’s Rich Gersten. The veteran investor recently departed Tengram Capital Partners and formed True Beauty Capital, a firm focused on budding beauty brands requiring injections of less than $10 million. Beauty Independent caught up with Gersten to discuss what he’s looking to accomplish through True Beauty Capital that he couldn’t accomplish before, his new company’s partnership with private equity outfit North Castle Partners and, of course, the impacts of the pandemic.
Why did you choose to strike out on your own with true beauty?
The idea around True Beauty and creating my own entity was to allow myself to be more opportunistic and have less constraints than I could being a partner in a fund. The way I think about it ultimately comes down to capital and resources in terms of how everything is pursued. I want it to be able to invest in things I thought made interesting investments regardless of their size and stage. In the past, I’ve been constrained by not being able to do smaller stuff because the funds had minimum investment amounts as part of their mandate and criteria. In theory, I don’t have those types of constraints anymore, although I have other types of constraints.
In the near term, I think my time will primarily be spent working on my portfolio companies with Tengram, which was an important part of this transition for me. I wouldn’t have wanted to not maintain those. It’s important for me to be able to maintain those relationships and fulfill my obligations. With North Castle Partners, any deals that involve $10 million or more, I’d bring to them on an exclusive basis. They make a good partner for me because I was a partner there for nine years. I know the people, the culture, the process, and the types of things they’re interested in line up well with me.
The things I haven’t been allowed to do in the past because I was a partner in a fund are being an advisor to a business [and] sitting on the boards of a business. I get asked that very frequently. It’s something I don’t think I can spend the lion’s share of my time on because I have other responsibilities and other, better ways of creating value for myself, but I don’t have the constraints on those [anymore]. I’ve had a couple of conversations with brands who are potentially interested in me joining as a board member and maybe following that up at some point in the future with an investment. Those things can also ultimately feed the investment side of the business.
What size deals will true beauty be looking at?
Any investments that are less than $10 million. There’s no current home for those. I can do a couple of things there. I can find another partner for those like I have for the larger ones with North Castle. I can try and do a couple [deals] early on by functioning as an independent sponsor and reaching out to my network to get funds raised for those deals [that will] be smaller by definition or, some point down the road, think of raising a small fund just to do those. That would involve me building out a team and infrastructure, and likely identifying someone to build and run that effort for me.
Historically, I haven’t been thought of for those small rounds. I’ve met lots of founders who are in that size range that haven’t thought of me for investing, and I’ve passed up interesting opportunities in my past to do smaller deals because I’d never been allowed to do them. The creation of True Beauty Capital hopefully allows me to exploit any opportunity in the beauty space within reason that I think is interesting because the constraints or mandate requirements of the fund have been removed.
Do you have any advice for independent brands trying to make it through the next six months to a year?
Our philosophy has been around shared pain and partnership. Whether your retail partner is asking you or not even asking you, [but] telling you they’re extending their terms, that’s hurting your cash flow. You’re going back to your vendors and doing the same. At some point, someone’s at the bottom of that chain getting it the worst. Your customers are asking you; we’re asking our vendors; we’re asking our lenders; we’re asking our employees, in some cases, to be furloughed and, in some cases, to take reduction in compensation. We’re asking our agencies and other vendor partners to lower their retainers or go on pause for a couple of months.
You try and trim as much non-essential spend as you can, and you revisit your inventory buying plan. I think the good news is, as we sit across a portfolio—Elana has done a great job of creating her own groups of other companies to share their experiences—what we’re learning is everybody’s effectively doing similar things. We’ve all coalesced around what the right strategies for survival are, and we’re all trying to execute them.
How do you think the coronavirus will impact retail distribution long term?
The fundamental demand drivers for beauty, broadly speaking, haven’t changed, and beauty has always been a resilient industry in terms of recovering from economic cycles and even performing well during economic downturns. I think the industry is set up for success and growth over the long term. You’ve got to think through your distribution strategies and understand if this will permanently change the way consumers shop, or will it change it in the short term and medium term, but people will revert to norms. At some point, people do forget. I get on planes now and don’t look around like I used to the first couple of years after 9/11.
The stores have to sanitize differently. Are testers with human touch by multiple people going to be used or are people going to be concerned? Department store counters who touch people’s faces with their hands to apply makeup and skincare, is that going to change? You have to think through your in store strategies. As a result, brands that may have resisted Amazon as a customer are probably revisiting it. Brands that we’re trying to prevent channel conflict on your own brand dot-com and your retailer’s dot-com maybe looking at other third-party dot-coms as a means to helping grow their business. I do think people are going to look at different ways of reaching the consumer that are more conducive to a new environment.
Direct-to-consumer brands have been hit hard by the current crisis. What do you think of the dtc model?
There are a lot of people who think stores are dead, and I don’t believe that. I don’t know what percentage of your business brick-and-mortar sales should be, but I fundamentally believe it’s not zero. Direct-to-consumer brand’s dot-coms need to complement the retailer’s dot-com and the retailer doors in a way that makes sense to grow your business profitably.
There are a lot of trends happening in beauty. There was an increasing penetration of e-commerce to overall sales. There was a share shift from department stores to specialty stores. There was Amazon slowly growing its presence in luxury and prestige beauty. All of these trends have been ongoing for years. Coronavirus may throw a little accelerant on those trends. It may quicken them or hasten them, but it fundamentally hasn’t changed them. I think [coronavirus] will continue to put pressure on the areas that were losing share.
What do you see the next few years looking like for investment in beauty?
There are a lot of indie brands that have historically had tough times accessing capital. Those may not survive. How long can you go without generating material cash and survive? There are lots of brands that focused only on growth at the expense of profitability. I think profitability matters. That was a trend that was happening that will be accelerated. I think it’s important to not grow at all costs. Values hopefully will come down a little bit. As a seller, it hurts me, but, as an investor, it helps me, and I think values have gotten away from historical norms in the pursuit of growth. I think that will change.
I do think there’ll be a new normal, I just don’t know what it looks like. A lot of brands raised money at big values, and those investors will realize that was a mistake, and they’ll need to raise more money. There’ll be down rounds. I think there could be some value for investors if they have the risk appetite to stomach uncertainty.
How do you think the strategics will move forward post-coronavirus?
I don’t think it ultimately changes their desire to use M&A as a growth strategy, but they may be chasing different things. They may be chasing brands with a better digital presence. Ultimately, what attracts me will attract them, which is an interesting and uniquely differentiated brand with a unique selling proposition. That’s interesting regardless of cycle. It all comes down to that. That’s always made me skeptical on influencer-created brands because those were more like celebrity brands. They may have had an interesting founder story, but that’s not the same, in my opinion, as some of the other brands that I’ve invested in the past and brands that make strategics interested.
When might we see the first deal from true beauty?
I’m a little skittish because of uncertainty. If I had some visibility as to what stores would open and when, and I had a little bit more conviction in what the recovery curve looked like, it would help. It would help because investors price and underwrite five-year plans and, then, invest in the business. If my portfolio companies today can’t, with any reliable precision, forecast what Q3 or Q4 of 2020 looks like, how is someone going to put together a credible five-year plan? So, I think it may take a little bit, but, again, I think investors have to be opportunistic and, if something interesting comes across or if something is growing right now because their digital presence accelerated their growth, those things can fetch capital much easier.
The Red Tree is the UK’s leading international beauty brand consultancy and a powerhouse of ideas, insight and inspiration. For an informal discussion on how we might help you, please contact us.
Middle East Beauty Hub
Explore our series of articles uncovering the intersection of tradition, innovation, and regulation within the nuanced Middle Eastern beauty markets.
Female Founders: The Lip Gloss Gap
Our series of articles highlighting how the UK beauty industry plays a vital part in closing the female fundraising gap.
New to the beauty industry? Our Founder Hub series brings together an array of articles covering topics from the costs of starting a new brand, to our recommended branding agencies.
Meet The Team
Get to know each of The Red Tree team members with our interview series. From our favourite campaigns to tips on how to enter the beauty industry.
Our series of articles exploring our fitness test for beauty brands. The unique RaceFit™ questionnaire allows you to quickly review the 7 building blocks crucial to brand success.
The Beauty Accelerator™
Read our series of articles focusing on The Beauty Accelerator™, which sees one emerging independent beauty brand receive equity investment plus the knowledge and expertise of The Red Tree.